Myrtle's Meatball Recipe Recipe on Food52 (2024)

Make Ahead

by: Sagegreen

August8,2010

4

5 Ratings

  • Serves a family of 3 to 5

Jump to Recipe

Author Notes

My mom was scarcely an avid cook, but she did make a few things really well, especially her meatballs, her beef stew, and her apple pie. Because she passed away recently, in her honor I want to preserve this recipe. This may not be award-winning to anybody else, but it is pretty special to me. She grew up with Fanny Farmer's cookbook and appreciated classic, simple, uncomplicated food. This meal brought contentment to everyone in our family. —Sagegreen

Test Kitchen Notes

Talk about comfort food. The kitchen was filled with a wonderful warmth and aroma from cooking up the meatballs and making the sauce. The meatballs were little bombs of flavor, tender and juicy. And the best thing was the simplicity. This recipe was a breeze to put together, a perfect option for during the week. We truly enjoyed this recipe! A special thanks to Sagegreen for sharing it with us. —adamnsvetcooking

  • Test Kitchen-Approved

What You'll Need

Ingredients
  • 3/4 cuprolled / old-fashioned oats
  • 1 (6 ounce) can tomato paste
  • 1 egg, beaten
  • 1/4 cupfresh, finely grated Parmesan cheese (plus additional for serving)
  • 1/2 teaspoondried thyme
  • 1/2 teaspoondried oregano
  • 1/2 teaspoonsalt (plus additional to taste)
  • generous dash of cracked black pepper
  • 1 poundmix of ground sirloin and chuck
  • Spray vegetable oil for pan if meat is lean (I use a heat-tolerate olive oil)
  • 1 large yellow onion, (1/3-inch chop)
  • 1 green pepper, seeded (1/3-inch chop)
  • 2 garlic cloves, peeled and chopped, if you are a garlic fan (this was not part of our early recipe)
  • 4 cupsstewed tomatoes with their juices, skins removed
  • 1/2 cuprosé wine (this was added later in our family and wasn't part of the early years of our recipe)
  • 1 bay leaf
  • Sprigs of fresh thyme, oregano, and marjoram
  • fresh parsley, chopped for garnish
Directions
  1. Mix the oatmeal, egg, cheese, thyme, oregano, 2 tablespoons of tomato paste, salt, and pepper together. Gently add the beef. Roll to form 1-inch balls.
  2. Spray a skillet with oil (if your beef is lean) and bring to high/medium-high heat.
  3. Add the meatballs to hot skillet to brown on all sides, but do not cook through, then transfer them to a plate (my mother put them directly into the Dutch oven).
  4. Saute the onion, green pepper, and garlic (if using) in the skillet. Add the rosé wine (this can help deglaze the pan) and then add everything in the skillet to the Dutch oven.
  5. Add and mix the remaining tomato paste, stewed tomatoes, and herb sprigs in the Dutch oven and bring to a simmer.
  6. Add the seared meatballs and continue to simmer slowly for 35 to 40 minutes. Adjust the seasoning, if needed.
  7. Remove the herb sprigs and bay leaf before serving. Serve with spaghetti and sprinkle with freshly grated Parmesan cheese and fresh chopped parsley.

Tags:

  • Meatball
  • Beef
  • Oregano
  • Parsley
  • Rosé
  • Thyme
  • Make Ahead
  • Entree
Contest Entries
  • Your Best Meatballs

Popular on Food52

18 Reviews

MrsBeeton November 9, 2020

Oh, this was so yummy! I used a mixture of ground pork and ground beef for added tenderness in the meat balls. And instead of simmering it on the stove, I just popped the Dutch oven in a 350 degree oven for about 45 minutes. Easy peasy, and totally delish. This one's a keeper.

Sagegreen November 12, 2020

Thanks, MrsBeeton! Glad to know that your oven method worked well with this recipe.

mdelgatty May 22, 2020

where is the photo of Mom?

Sagegreen May 22, 2020

Use the white cursor arrow (in the middle of the first photo) to scroll on over to it!

Sagegreen August 15, 2010

I think I grew up overcooking meatballs! Probably the times on all my recipes should be reduced.

zazafrasca August 13, 2010

Mom's do make the best meatballs. I hope you post Myrtle's Apple Pie recipe someday. Fantastic picture. What a glamorous mother you had.

Sagegreen August 13, 2010

Thanks! I will be making the pie this fall: it was her very best recipe.

JoanG August 10, 2010

I have enjoyed a similar recipe, also cooked ina meatloaf. Lovely tribute to your mom! My mother had the same approach to cooking as yours ,and also loved her Fanny farmer cookbook.

Sagegreen August 11, 2010

My mom had the exact same recipe for meatloaf now that you mention that!

drbabs August 10, 2010

So glad you posted this! In May we had a "best thing your mother taught you" contest and we all posted photos of our moms--so glad you were able to post yours.

Sagegreen August 10, 2010

Sorry I hadn't discovered the site then. That is a contest I will have to find to take a look.

Lizthechef August 10, 2010

Yes, check out the Mom's Day posts - they are wonderful. Love the light in your Mom's eyes - thumbs up!

adamnsvetcooking August 10, 2010

Your mom was very pretty, and her recipe sounds amazing! I am always bias to a recipe that has a bay leaf in the ingredients list.

Sagegreen August 10, 2010

Thnaks. She was pretty wonderful!

Lizthechef August 8, 2010

So sorry you lost your Mom! My mother is gone now as well, and she was a Fanny Farmer fan too, as am I. Thanks for sharing her recipe - lovely photo!

Sagegreen August 8, 2010

Thanks. You are welcome. I was reared on Fanny Farmer! It is a classic.

lapadia August 8, 2010

Pretty picture of your mom, and hats off to your mom's meatballs!

Sagegreen August 8, 2010

Thank you!

Myrtle's Meatball Recipe Recipe on Food52 (2024)

FAQs

How many meatballs from 2 lbs of meat? ›

Example: Small meatballs= 20 per pound; 5 X 20= 100; Halve the mixture 2 x 50; 10 x 5 and so forth. Form balls out of the square pieces of meat mixture. Place on greased baking sheet. Bake at 350 F until done.

How many meatballs per person for a party? ›

A quick guide to figure out how many meatballs you need is as follows: If you are serving 2-ounce meatballs you should plan on having 3 meatballs per person. Therefore, for 50 people you will need 150 2-ounce meatballs. These will also be 2-inch meatballs or the size of a golf ball.

How many frozen meatballs for 100 guests? ›

The number of meatballs needed for 100 people depends upon their size and the manner in which they are served. A standard main course serving size is 6 ounces of meat per guest, or approximately 600 1-ounce meatballs, 400 1 1/2-ounce meatballs, 300 2-ounce meatballs and 200 3-ounce meatballs.

What not to do when making meatballs? ›

5 Mistakes to Avoid When Making Meatballs
  1. Not seasoning the meat.
  2. Not adding any moisture to the meat.
  3. Over-mixing the meat.
  4. Not shaping the meatballs correctly.
  5. Not forming evenly-sized meatballs.
May 1, 2019

Is it better to bake meatballs at 350 or 400? ›

For 1-2 inches of beef, pork, or turkey meatballs without any pre-cooking, use these guidelines for your wall oven:
  • 350°F wall oven:
  • 8–14 minutes for 1-inch meatballs.
  • 14–18 minutes for 2-inch meatballs.
  • 400°F wall oven:
  • 6–10 minutes for 1-inch meatballs.
  • 10–14 minutes for 2-inch meatballs.
  • 425°F wall oven:
Aug 16, 2023

How much meat do I need for 20 guests? ›

In other words, if you're cooking for 10 people, you'll want at least five pounds of meat total. For 20 people, plan to purchase 10 or more pounds of meat.

How much food to make for 50 guests? ›

Food for Dinner Parties
FoodUp to 10 guests40-50
Whole chicken2 (4-pound)10 (4-pound)
Whole turkey1 (12-pound)5 (12-pound)
Boneless beef roast5 pounds25 pounds
Pork roast or ham5 pounds25 pounds
9 more rows

How many meatballs are required for a party of 10? ›

It really depends on how many meatballs each person will eat. On average, each adult may eat around 6-8 meatballs, and each child may eat around 4-6 meatballs. So for 10 adults, you may need 60-80 meatballs, and for 5 children, you may need 20-30 meatballs. In total, you may need 80-110 meatballs for this party.

How many pounds of ground beef for 50 people? ›

I would suggest a quarter-pound ground beef/pork per person. That works out to about 12–1/2 - 13 pounds. You might have some leftover, but better that than having too little.

How to spruce up frozen meatballs? ›

10 Ways to Turn Frozen Meatballs into an Easy Weeknight Dinner
  1. Turn them into hearty subs. ...
  2. Toss them in the slow cooker. ...
  3. Make a pizza out of them. ...
  4. Grill them on skewers. ...
  5. Skip IKEA and make your own Köttbullar. ...
  6. Get bowled over. ...
  7. Add a little touch of Catalonia. ...
  8. Bake them into a casserole.
Sep 12, 2019

How many meatballs is enough? ›

If you're planning to buy ready made, I'd go with at least 3 per person. Maybe 4 if you have a lot of big eaters. Plus the longer meatballs simmer in sauce the better they taste. And they can be frozen,sauce and all.

Why do my homemade meatballs fall apart? ›

Because meat shrinks when cooked, mince proteins are likely to separate and crumble unless bound together. Whether it's breadcrumbs or egg (or both), or simply salt, binding the mince is a crucial step in maintaining the softness of your meatballs while preventing them from falling apart.

Can you add too much egg to meatballs? ›

Add a lightly beaten egg, but not too much. Egg acts as a binder for the ingredients, but you only need a small amount. One small egg will do for one pound of minced meat.

Why add water to meatballs? ›

To add even more moisture, and to help the bread break down into the blend, it soaks in a liquid first. A lot of recipes call for water or milk, but I wanted really full-flavored meatballs here, so I experimented with a few different liquids, including milk, red wine, and buttermilk.

How much does 2 pounds of meat feed? ›

What weight of meat per person to order?
Boneless MeatNumber of PeopleBone in meat
1lb / 0.45kg2 – 3
2lb / 0.91kg4 – 53lb / 1.36kg
3lb / 1.36kg6 – 74lb / 1.82kg
4lb / 1.82kg8 – 96lb / 2.73kg
8 more rows

How many pounds of meatballs do I need for 12 people? ›

Here's how many meatballs per person you'll need: One serving = 4 meatballs. Party of 12 = 2 pounds.

Is 2 lbs of meat enough for 3 people? ›

A question we often get is “How much meat do I need?” The starting rule of thumb is: Boneless Meat: 1/2 lb. per person for adults and 1/4 lb. per person for children.

How much does 1lb of ground meat feed? ›

A serving is 4 oz cooked, which means 1 lb of ground beef is good for around 3 servings after water loss and cooking.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Msgr. Benton Quitzon

Last Updated:

Views: 5559

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Msgr. Benton Quitzon

Birthday: 2001-08-13

Address: 96487 Kris Cliff, Teresiafurt, WI 95201

Phone: +9418513585781

Job: Senior Designer

Hobby: Calligraphy, Rowing, Vacation, Geocaching, Web surfing, Electronics, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Msgr. Benton Quitzon, I am a comfortable, charming, thankful, happy, adventurous, handsome, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.